OUCH! 6d6+6 is what, 27HP average on a failed save? Would've taken me from full to dying. Good job that cavalier!
(I don't think the DM was being serious.)
]]>]]>Actually that was the 60hp elemental destroyer. Basically if it was not killed in round two it was going to create an earthquake dealing 6d6+6 damage to the party (save for half). Fortunately you killed it before it could use the ability, saving the party. But if you say you worked out the damage wrong that could be an issue.
]]>So I think I might have gotten my 61 damage wrong due to the peculiarities of Pathfinder/D&D multipliers. x3 damage for the charge x3 damage for the crit should give x5 damage, not x9 I think. So my critical charge should have dealt only 5d6+15, not 9d6+27.
Still, should be enough to kill the elemental I think, so it shouldn't change the outcome of the fight any.